2025 | Kevin Byard | Chicago Bears | 7 |
2024 | Kerby Joseph | Detroit Lions | 9 |
2023 | DaRon Bland | Dallas Cowboys | 9 |
2022 | Justin Simmons | Denver Broncos | 6 |
| Minka Fitzpatrick | Pittsburgh Steelers | 6 |
| C.J. Gardner-Johnson | Philadelphia Eagles | 6 |
| Riq Woolen | Seattle Seahawks | 6 |
2021 | Trevon Diggs | Dallas Cowboys | 11 |
2020 | Xavien Howard | Miami Dolphins | 10 |
2019 | Stephon Gilmore | New England Patriots | 6 |
| Anthony Harris | Minnesota Vikings | 6 |
| Tre'Davious White | Buffalo Bills | 6 |
2018 | Kyle Fuller | Chicago Bears | 7 |
| Xavien Howard | Miami Dolphins | 7 |
| Damontae Kazee | Atlanta Falcons | 7 |
2017 | Kevin Bayard | Tennessee Titans | 8 |
| Darius Slay | Detroit Lions | 8 |
2016 | Casey Hayward | San Diego Chargers | 7 |
2015 | Reggie Nelson | Cincinnati Bengals | 8 |
| Marcus Peters | Kansas City Chiefs | 8 |
2014 | Glover Quin | Detroit Lions | 7 |
2013 | Richard Sherman | Seatte Seahawks | 8 |
2012 | Tim Jennings | Chicago Bears | 9 |
2011 | Kyle Arrington | New England Patriots | 7 |
| Eric Weddle | San Diego Chargers | 7 |
| Charles Woodson | Green Bay Packers | 7 |
2010 | Ed Reed | Baltimore Ravens | 8 |
2009 | Darren Sharper | New Orleans Saints | 9 | |
| Charles Woodson | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
| Jairus Byrd | Buffalo Bills | 9 |
| Asante Samuel | Philadelphia Eagles | 9 |
2008 | Ed Reed | Baltimore Ravens | 9 |
2007 | Antonio Cormartie | San Diego Chargers | 10 |
2006 | Asante Samuel | New England Patriots | 10 |
| Champ Bailey | Denver Broncos | 10 |
2005 | Ty Law | New York Jets | 10 |
| Deltha O'Neal | Cinncinati Bengals | 10 |
2004 | Ed Reed | Baltimore Ravens | 9 |
2003 | Brian Russell | Minnesota Vikings | 9 |
| Tony Parrish | San Francisco 49ers | 9 |
2002 | Rod Woodson | Oakland Raiders | 8 |
| Brian Kelly | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 8 |
2001 | Ronde Barber | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 10 |
| Anthony Henry | Cleveland Browns | 10 |
2000 | Darren Sharper | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
1999 | Rod Woodson | Baltimore Ravens | 7 |
| Sam Madison | Miami Dolphins | 7 |
| James Hasty | Kansas City Chiefs | 7 |
| Donnie Abraham | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 7 |
| Troy Vincent | Philadelphia Eagles | 7 |
1998 | Ty Law | New England Patriots | 9 |
1997 | Ryan McNeil | St. Louis Rams | 9 |
1996 | Tyrone Braxton | Denver Broncos | 9 |
| Keith Lyle | St. Louis Rams | 9 |
1995 | Orlando Thomas | Minnesota Vikings | 9 |
1994 | Eric Turner | Cleveland Browns | 9 |
| Aeneas Williams | Arizona Cardinals | 9 |
1993 | Eugene Robinson | Seattle Seahawks | 9 |
| Nate Odomes | Buffalo Bills | 9 |
1992 | Henry Jones | Buffalo Bills | 8 |
| Audray McMillian | Minnesota Vikings | 8 |
1991 | Ronnie Lott | Los Angeles Raiders | 8 |
1990 | Mark Carrier | Chicago Bears | 10 |
1989 | Felix Wright | Cleveland Browns | 9 |
1988 | Scott Case | Atlanta Falcons | 10 |
1987 | Barry Wilburn | Washington Redskins | 9 |
1986 | Ronnie Lott | San Francisco 49ers | 10 |
1985 | Everson Walls | Dallas Cowboys | 9 |
1984 | Ken Easley | Seattle Seahawks | 10 |
1983 | Mark Murphy | Washington Redskins | 9 |
1982 | Everson Walls | Dallas Cowboys | 7 |
1981 | Everson Walls | Dallas Cowboys | 11 |
1980 | Lester Hayes | Oakland Raiders | 13 |
1979 | Mike Reinfeldt | Houston Oilers | 12 |
1978 | Thom Darden | Cleveland Browns | 10 |
1977 | Lyle Blackwood | Baltimore Colts | 10 |
1976 | Monte Jackson | Los Angeles Rams | 10 |
1975 | Mel Blount | Pittsburgh Steelers | 11 |
1974 | Emmitt Thomas | Kansas City Chiefs | 12 |
1973 | Dick Anderson | Miami Dolphins | 8 |
| Mike Wagner | Pittsburgh Steelers | 8 |
1972 | Bill Bradley | Philadelphia Eagles | 9 |
1971 | Bill Bradley | Philadelphia Eagles | 11 |
1970 | Johnny Robinson | Kansas City Chiefs | 10 |
1969 | NFL: Mel Renfro | Dallas Cowboys | 10 |
| AFL: Emmitt Thomas | Kansas City Chiefs | 9 |
1968 | NFL: Willie Williams | New York Giants | 10 |
| AFL: Dave Grayson | Oakland Raiders | 10 |
1967 | NFL: Lem Barney | Detroit Lions | 10 |
| NFL: Dave Whitsell | New Orleans Saints | 10 |
| AFL: Miller Farr | Houston Oilers | 10 |
| AFL: Tom Janik | Buffalo Bills | 10 |
| AFL: Dick Westmoreland | Miami Dolphins | 10 |
1966 | NFL: Larry Wilson | St. Louis Cardinals | 10 |
| AFL: Johnny Robinson | Kansas City Chiefs | 10 |
| AFL: Bobby Hunt | Kansas City Chiefs | 10 |
1965 | NFL: Bobby Boyd | Baltimore Colts | 9 |
| AFL: W.K. Hicks | Houston Oilers | 9 |
1964 | NFL: Paul Krause | Washington Redskins | 12 |
| AFL: Dainard Paulson | New York Jets | 12 |
1963 | NFL: Dick Lynch | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
| NFL: Roosevelt Taylor | Chicago Bears | 9 |
| AFL: Fred Glick | Houston Oilers | 12 |
1962 | NFL: Willie Wood | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
| AFL: Lee Riley | New York Titans | 11 |
1961 | NFL: Dick Lynch | New York Giants | 9 |
| AFL: Billy Atkins | Buffalo Bills | 10 |
1960 | NFL: Dave Backer | San Francisco 49ers | 10 |
| NFL: Jerry Norton | St. Louis Cardinals | 10 |
| AFL: Austin Gonsouliln | Denver Broncos | 11 |
1959 | Dean Derby | Pittsburgh Steelers | 7 |
| Milt Davis | Baltimore Colts | 7 |
| Don Shinnick | Baltimore Colts | 7 |
1958 | Jim Patton | New York Giants | 11 |
1957 | Milt Davis | Baltimore Colts | 10 |
| Jack Christiansen | Detroit Lions | 10 |
| Jack Butler | Pittsburgh Steelers | 10 |
1956 | Linden Crow | Chicago Cardinals | 11 |
1955 | Will Sherman | Los Angeles Rams | 11 |
1954 | Dick Lane | Chicago Cardinals | 10 |
1953 | Jack Christiansen | Detroit Lions | 12 |
1952 | Dick Lane | Los Angeles Rams | 14* |
1951 | Otto Schnellbacher | New York Giants | 11 |
1950 | Orban Sanders | New York Yanks | 13 |
1949 | NFL: Bob Nussbaumer | Chicago Cardinals | 12 |
| AAFC: Jim Cason | San Francisco 49ers | 9 |
1948 | NFL: Dan Sandifer | Washington Redskins | 13 |
| AAFC: Otto Schnellbacher | New York Yankees | 11 |
1947 | NFL: Frank Reagan | New York Giants | 10 |
| NFL: Frank Seno | Boston Yanks | 10 |
| AAFC: Tom Colella | Cleveland Browns | 6 |
| AAFC: Bill Kellagher | Chicago Rockets | 6 |
| AAFC: Len Eshmont | San Francisco 49ers | 6 |
1946 | NFL: Bill Dudley | Pittsburgh Steelers | 10 |
| AAFC: Tom Colella | Cleveland Browns | 10 |
1945 | Roy Zimmerman | Philadelphia Eagles | 7 |
1944 | Howard Livingston | New York Giants | 9 |
1943 | Sammy Baugh | Washington Redskins | 11 |
1942 | Clyde Turner | Chicago Bears | 8 |
1941 | Marshall Goldberg | Chicago Cardinals | 7 |
| Art Jones | Pittsburgh Steelers | 7 |
1940 | Clarence Parker | Brooklyn Dodgers | 6 |
| Kent Ryan | Detroit Lions | 6 |
| Don Hutson | Green Bay Packers | 6 |
*: NFL-Rekord
Anmerkung: Die offiziellen NFL-Statistiken werden seit 1932 erhoben. Neben ihren eigenen Statistiken sind von der NFL auch die Statistiken der AFL (1960-1969) offiziell anerkannt.
