2025 | Kai'mi Fairbarn | Houston Texans | 44* |
2024 | Chris Boswell | Pittsburgh Steelers | 41 |
2023 | Brandon Aubrey | Dallas Cowboys | 36 |
2022 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | 37 |
2021 | Daniel Carlson | Las Vegas Raiders | 40 |
2020 | Younghoe Koo | Atlanta Falcons | 37 |
2019 | Harrison Butker | Kansas City Chiefs | 34 |
2018 | Kai'mi Fairbarn | Houston Texans | 37 |
2017 | Robbie Gould | San Francisco 49ers | 39 |
2016 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | 38 |
2015 | Blair Walsh | Minnesota Vikings | 34 |
2014 | Stephen Gostkowski | New England Patriots | 35 |
2013 | Stephen Gostkowski | New England Patriots | 38 |
| Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | 38 |
2012 | Blair Walsh | Minnesota Vikings | 35 |
2011 | David Akers | San Francisco 49ers | 44* |
2010 | Josh Brown | St. Louis Rams | 33 |
| Sebastian Janikowski | Oakland Raiders | 33 |
2009 | David Akers | Philadelphia Eagles | 32 |
| Nate Kaeding | San Diego Chargers | 32 |
2008 | Stephen Gostkowski | New England Patriots | 36 |
2007 | Rob Bironas | Tennessee Titans | 35 |
2006 | Robbie Gould | Chicago Bears | 32 |
| Jeff Wilkins | St. Louis Rams | 32 |
2005 | Neil Rackers | Arizona Cardinals | 40 |
2004 | Adam Vinatieri | New England Patriots | 31 |
2003 | Jeff Wilkins | St. Louis Rams | 39 |
2002 | Martin Gramatica | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 32 |
| Jay Feely | Atlanta Falcons | 32 |
2001 | Jason Elam | Denver Broncos | 31 |
2000 | Matt Stover | Baltimore Ravens | 35 |
1999 | Olindo Mare | Miami Dolphins | 39 |
1998 | Al Del Greco | Tennessee Oilers | 36 |
1997 | Richie Cunningham | Dallas Cowboys | 34 |
1996 | John Kasay | Carolina Panthers | 37 |
1995 | Norm Johnson | Pittsburgh Steelers | 34 |
1994 | John Carney | San Diego Chargers | 34 |
1993 | Jeff Jaeger | Los Angeles Raiders | 35 |
1992 | Pete Stoyanovich | Miami Dolphins | 30 |
| Chip Lohmiller | Washington Redskins | 30 |
1991 | Pete Stoyanovich | Miami Dolphins | 31 |
| Chip Lohmiller | Washington Redskins | 31 |
1990 | Nick Lowery | Kansas City Chiefs | 34 |
1989 | Rich Karlis | Minnesota Vikings | 31 |
1988 | Scott Norwood | Buffalo Bills | 32 |
1987 | Morten Andersen | New Orleans Saints | 28 |
1986 | Tony Franklin | New England Patriots | 32 |
1985 | Gary Anderson | Pittsburgh Steelers | 33 |
1984 | Paul McFadden | Philadelphia Eagles | 30 |
1983 | Ali Haji-Sheikh | New York Giants | 35 |
1982 | Mark Moseley | Washington Redskins | 20 |
1981 | Rafael Septien | Dallas Cowboys | 27 |
1980 | Ed Murray | Detroit Lions | 27 |
1979 | Mark Moseley | Washington Redskins | 25 |
1978 | Frank Corral | Los Angeles Rams | 29 |
1977 | Mark Moseley | Washington Redskins | 21 |
1976 | Mark Moseley | Washington Redskins | 22 |
1975 | Jan Stenerud | Kansas City Chiefs | 22 |
| Toni Fritsch | Dallas Cowboys | 22 |
1974 | Chester Marcol | Green Bay Packers | 25 |
1973 | David Ray | Los Angeles Rams | 30 |
1972 | Chester Marcol | Green Bay Packers | 33 |
1971 | Curt Knight | Washington Redskins | 29 |
1970 | Jan Stenerud | Kansas City Chiefs | 30 |
| Fred Cox | Minnesota Vikings | 30 |
1969 | NFL: Fred Cox | Minnesota Vikings | 26 |
| AFL: Jim Turner | New York Jets | 32 |
1968 | NFL: Mac Percival | Chicago Bears | 25 |
| AFL: Jim Turner | New York Jets | 34 |
1967 | NFL: Jim Baken | St. Louis Cardinals | 27 |
| AFL: Jan Stenerud | Kansas City Chiefs | 21 |
1966 | NFL: Bruce Gossett | Los Angeles Rams | 28 |
| AFL: Mike Mercer | Kansas City Chiefs** | 21 |
1965 | NFL: Fred Cox | Minnesota Vikings | 23 |
| AFL: Pete Gogolak | Buffalo Bills | 28 |
1964 | NFL: Jim Bakken | St. Louis Cardinals | 25 |
| AFL: Gino Cappelletti | Boston Patriots | 25 |
1963 | NFL: Jim Martin | Baltimore Colts | 24 |
| AFL: Gino Cappelletti | Boston Patriots | 22 |
1962 | NFL: Lou Michaels | Pittsburgh Steelers | 26 |
| AFL: Gene Mingo | Denver Broncos | 27 |
1961 | NFL: Steve Myhra | Baltimore Colts | 21 |
| AFL: Gino Cappelletti | Boston Patriots | 17 |
1960 | NFL: Tommy Davis | San Francisco 49ers | 19 |
| AFL: Gene Mingo | Denver Broncos | 18 |
1959 | Pat Summerall | New York Giants | 20 |
1958 | Paige Cothren | Los Angeles Rams | 14 |
| Tom Miner | Pittsburgh Steelers | 14 |
1957 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 15 |
1956 | Sam Baker | Washington Redskins | 17 |
1955 | Fred Cone | Green Bay Packers | 16 |
1954 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 16 |
1953 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 23 |
1952 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 19 |
1951 | Bob Waterfield | Los Angeles Rams | 13 |
1950 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 13 |
1949 | NFL: Cliff Patton | Philadelphia Eagles | 9 |
| NFL: Bob Waterfield | Los Angeles Rams | 9 |
| AAFC: Harvey Johnson | New York Yankees | 7 |
1948 | NFL: Cliff Patton | Philadelphia Eagles | 8 |
| AAFC: Rex Grossman | Baltimore Colts | 10 |
1947 | NFL: Ward Cuff | Green Bay Packers | 7 |
| NFL: Pat Harder | Chicago Cardinals | 7 |
| NFL: Bob Waterfield | Los Angeles Rams | 7 |
| AAFC: Ben Agajanian | Los Angeles Dons | 15 |
1946 | NFL: Ted Fritsch | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
| AAFC: Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | 13 |
1945 | Joe Aguirre | Washington Redskins | 7 |
1944 | Ken Strong | New York Giants | 6 |
1943 | Ward Cuff | New York Giants | 3 |
| Don Hutson | Green Bay Packers | 3 |
1942 | Bill Daddio | Chicago Cardinals | 5 |
1941 | Clarke Hinkle | Green Bay Packers | 6 |
1940 | Clarke Hinkle | Green Bay Packers | 9 |
1939 | Ward Cuff | New York Giants | 7 |
1938 | Ward Cuff | New York Giants | 5 |
| Ralph Kercheval | Brooklyn Dodgers | 5 |
1937 | Jack Manders | Chicago Bears | 8 |
1936 | Jack Manders | Chicago Bears | 7 |
| Armand Niccolai | Pittsburgh Pirates | 7 |
1935 | Armand Niccolai | Pittsburgh Pirates | 6 |
| Bil Smith | Chicago Cardinals | 6 |
1934 | Jack Manders | Chicago Bears | 10 |
1933 | Jack Manders | Chicago Bears | 6 |
| Glenn Presnell | Portsmouth Spartans | 6 |
1932 | Earl Clark | Portsmouth Spartans | 3 |
*: NFL-Rekord
**:spielte zwei Spiele für die Oakland Raiders
Anmerkung: Die offiziellen NFL-Statistiken werden seit 1932 erhoben. Neben ihren eigenen Statistiken sind von der NFL auch die Statistiken der AFL (1960-1969) offiziell anerkannt.
