Position	Erstes Team	Zweites Team
			.
OFFENSE
WR	Reggie Wayne	Pierre Garcon
LT	Charlie Johnson	Tony Ugoh
LG	Ryan Lilja	Jamey Richard
C	Jeff Saturday	Kyle DeVan
RG	Mike Pollak	Daniel Federkeil
RT	Ryan Diem	Tony Ugoh
TE	Dallas Clark	Tom Santi
WR	Anthony Gonzalez	Austin Collie
QB	Peyton Manning	Jim Sorgi
RB	Joseph Addai	Donald Brown
FB	Gijon Robinson	Jacob Tamme
			.
DEFFENSE
RDE	Dwight Freeney	Raheem Brock
RDT	Fili Moala	Eric Foster
LDT	Antonio Johnson	Daniel Muir
LDE	Robert Mathis	Keyunta Dawson
SLB	Clint Session	Ramon Humber
MLB	Gary Brackett	Freddy Keiaho
WLB	Philip Wheeler	Tyjuan Hagler
CB	Marlin Jackson	Tim Jennings
SS	Bob Sanders	Melvin Bullitt
FS	Antoine Bethea	Aaron Francisco
CB	Kelvin Hayden	T.J. Rushing
			.
SPECIAL TEAMS
K	Adam Vinatieri
P	Pat McAfee
LS	Justin Snow
H	Pat McAffee
PR	T.J. Rushing	Pierre Garcon
KR	Chad Simpson	T.J. Rushing

Stand zu Beginn der Saison 2009