Position	Erstes Team	Zweites Team
			.
OFFENSE
WR	Domenik Hixon	Mario Manningham
LT	David Diehl	William Beatty
LG	Rich Seubert	Tutan Reyes
C	Shaun O'Hara	Adam Koets
RG	Chris Snee	Kevin Boothe
RT	Kareem McKenzie	Guy Whimper
TE	Kevin Boss	Travis Beckum
WR	Steve Smith	Sinorice Moss
QB	Eli Manning	David Carr
RB	Brandon Jacobs	Ahmad Bradshaw
FB	Madison Hedgecock	Dwayne Wright
			.
DEFFENSE
RDE	Osi Umenyiora	Dave Tollefson
RDT	Fred Robbins	Rocky Bernard
LDT	Barry Coefield	Chris Canty
LDE	Justin Tuck	Mathias Kiwanuka
SLB	Danny Clark	Clint Sintim
MLB	Antonio Pierce	Chase Blackburn
WLB	Bryan Kehl	Gerris Wilkinson
CB	Corey Webster	Kevin Dockery
SS	Michael Johnson	C.C. Brown
FS	Kenny Phillips	Steve Cargile
CB	Terrell Thomas	Aaron Ross
			.
SPECIAL TEAMS
K	Lawrence Tynes
P	Jeff Feagles
LS	Zak DeOssie
H	Jeff Feagles
PR	Domenik Hixon	Ahmad Bradshaw
KR	Ahmad Bradshaw	Domenik Hixon

Stand zu Beginn der Saison 2009