2023 | Joe Flacco | Quarterback | Cleveland Browns |
2022 | Geno Smith | Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks |
2021 | Joe Burrow | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals |
2020 | Alex Smith | Quarterback | Washington Football Team |
2019 | Ryan Tannehill | Quarterback | Tennessee Titans |
2018 | Andrew Luck | Quarterback | Indianapolis Colts |
2017 | Keenan Allen | Wide Receiver | Los Angeles Chargers |
2016 | Jordy Nelson | Wide Receiver | Green Bay Packers |
2015 | Eric Berry | Safety | Kansas City Chiefs |
2014 | Rob Gronkowski | Tight End | New England Patriots |
2013 | Philip Rivers | Quarterback | San Diego Chargers |
2012 | Peyton Manning | Quarterback | Denver Broncos |
2011 | Matthew Stafford | Quarterback | Detroit Lions |
2010 | Michael Vick | Quarterback | Philadelphia Eagles |
2009 | Tom Brady | Quarterback | New England Patriots |
2008 | Chad Pennington | Quarterback | Miami Dolphins |
2007 | Greg Ellis | Linebacker | Dallas Cowboys |
2006 | Chad Pennington | Quarterback | New York Jets |
2005 | Tedy Bruschi | Linebacker | New England Patriots |
| Steve Smith | Wide Receiver | Carolina Panthers |
2004 | Drew Brees | Quarterback | San Diego Chargers |
2003 | Jon Kitna | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals |
2002 | Tommy Maddox | Quarterback | Pittsburgh Steelers |
2001 | Garrison Hearst | Running Back | San Francisco 49ers |
2000 | Joe Johnson | Defensive End | New Orleans Saints |
1999 | Bryant Young | Defensive Tackle | San Francisco 49ers |
1998 | Doug Flutie | Quarterback | Buffalo Bills |
Der Award wird jährlich von der Nachrichtenagentur AP vergeben.